Chris Locke is Co-Founder of LockSmith, a business that trains marketers. Earlier in his career, he worked with Coca-Cola, Diageo, The National Lottery, Lily’s Kitchen, and The Collective, and at Diageo he ran a portfolio of brands across Europe, Smirnoff and Gordon’s among them, with a £125 million marketing budget and a team of 55. He set up LockSmith with his business partner Alex Smith six years ago, so he has had to make small-budget marketing work from the founder’s chair as well.
In this session, Chris covered small budget marketing by running a simulation: a made-up oat bar brand called Oatsider, £100,000 to invest over the next 12 months, and six decisions that most marketers will recognise, with the audience voting live on each one. It matters because so many marketing case studies end with the line that the team had a huge budget to spend.
The short version
Small budget marketing starts with finding out why sales have stalled, then choosing one audience and one fight that a bigger competitor can’t easily follow you into. In Chris Locke’s worked example, cash flow put 80% of a £100,000 budget behind sales and 20% behind brand, and he said the plan needs the founder’s sign-off and a joint plan with the sales team. He opened with a plain instruction: stop moaning about what you don’t have and make the most of what you do.
How do you approach small budget marketing when every case study had millions?
Start with what you have that a bigger competitor would envy, because nothing changes while you measure yourself against their budget. Chris said “tiny” is relative: some teams have pennies, others have a budget that is simply far smaller than the competition’s, and the question for both is how to win with constrained resources.
He put his own experience on the table. At Diageo, he had £125 million to spend and it still wasn’t enough, with a team of 55 and more he wanted to do than the money allowed. His instruction was blunt: “stop moaning about what you don’t have.”
He showed an ad from Surreal cereal as an example of using what a challenger has. It plays on celebrity by pointing at a man called Dwayne Johnson, who is not the actor but does enjoy the cereal, with a large caveat on the poster. Chris’s point was that a brand like Kellogg’s would not get an ad like that past its legal and regulatory teams, while a challenger can try things like it every day.
What comes first in small budget marketing when sales go flat?
Find out why before you spend anything, because the quickest-looking fix is often the wrong one. In the simulation, Oatsider is three years old, turns over £1.5 million, and has 12 people, two of them in marketing. It sells high-protein oat bars that taste like a flapjack, in four flavours, and one of them, tropical, is struggling. Trial is good, but repeat is weak; sales have been flat for two quarters, and a retailer’s range review in six months could drop the brand. The founder is certain the main buyer is a gym-goer, and a category giant called Goliath is the main rival.
The audience had three options: launch two new flavours, talk to lapsed buyers and blind test against rivals, or run 25% off. Most chose to understand why, and Chris agreed. He pointed to double jeopardy from Byron Sharp’s How Brands Grow: a small brand has fewer buyers and so fewer repeat buyers, which makes everything harder but not impossible.
His own example was Smirnoff Ice. When he joined Diageo to run Smirnoff in the UK, the received wisdom was that Smirnoff Ice recruited drinkers to Smirnoff Vodka. It did not. The drinkers were a different audience, in a different occasion, with a different need, so the plans changed. Research can be cheap, through online panels, white papers, libraries, or simply talking to consumers yourself. In Chris’s words: “There is never a good reason for not finding out what is going on.”
Oatsider’s interviews found that people liked the product and the pack, especially its “3PM pick me up” line, that tropical was not selling, and that Goliath’s salted caramel was popular. The response was to swap tropical for salted caramel, keep the range tight, and leave the pack alone.
How do you choose a proposition in small budget marketing?
Choose the narrowest proposition you can afford to own, and get it signed off. Oatsider’s three options were high-protein, high-fibre oat bars for active lives aimed at desk workers and gym-goers, delicious snacks for any time, or a 3 PM pick-me-up that tastes like a proper flapjack, aimed at desk workers only. Chris chose the third.
Byron Sharp’s advice to reach as many category buyers as possible still applies, he said, with the caveat that it means as many as you can afford to reach, without spreading yourself thin. Focusing on the 3 PM slump gives a bigger impact than a wider audience would. His reasoning was simple: we all know we should eat healthier, but at 3 pm a mouthful of lettuce does not cut it.
That choice came with a list of things not to buy: no rebrand, no new website, no heavy spend on brand tracking, and no pretending a £100,000 budget can buy national reach. Chris said he has not yet seen a rebrand pay back, because they cost a fortune and most of the time miss the real problem.
Then comes the harder part. Get the proposition written down, signed off, and stuck to, so that everyone can move fast without waiting. Founders change their minds, so remind them of the decisions made, the research behind them, and what focus gives you over distraction. Chris said he isn’t promising it’s easy, and that he has lived through it.
How can a small brand compete with a much bigger competitor?
Pick a fight the bigger competitor cannot or will not follow you into, and be a big fish in a small pond. In the simulation, Goliath launches a protein oat bar with a two-for-£2 deal and a TV campaign. The options were to match the price, hold the price and put money into office sampling, or move half the budget into national paid social. Most chose to hold the price and sample.
Chris said you can’t take Goliath on head-to-head. Shoppers recognise a nationally known brand, a TV ad lands because the name is familiar, and awareness makes people assume the product is good and worth the price. Big brands also seldom do sampling, because they struggle to justify its return, and they don’t do fast, riskier creator-led social the way a challenger can.
So Oatsider focuses on office workers at the 3PM slump in two cities, Manchester and Leeds, and on convenience stores near those offices and food service suppliers such as Compass and Sodexo. Sampling is supported by vouchers that take people to local stores, point-of-sale, and social, because hope is not a strategy. Because the effort is concentrated, it can be measured and used as a case study for the founder and the retailers.
Chris’s own business made a similar choice. He said 95% of B2B buyers aren’t looking for your services at any given moment, so LockSmith chose one channel, LinkedIn, and parked TikTok, Instagram, and Substack because the team couldn’t resource them. In hindsight, he would have started earlier with more PR, speaking at events, and long-form content that shows what he knows.
How should you split a small marketing budget between brand and sales?
It depends on your stage, budget, and competitors, and in Chris’s example, cash flow decided it: 80% on sales and 20% on brand. The audience’s options were all sales, 60% brand and 40% sales as Binet and Field advise in The Long and the Short of It, or 80% sales and 20% brand. The votes were much closer than on the earlier questions.
Chris said Binet and Field’s principle is sound, and that Grace Kite’s paper The Wrong and the Short of It adds that the right split depends on where you are in the product life cycle, how much you have to spend, and what the competitors look like. For a small business, cash flow and protecting the retailer listing mattered most.
He borrowed Kite’s framing of sales as demand harvesting: converting people who are in the market now. That gets hard if the proposition, distribution, or value for money is weak, or if you have already converted everyone likely to buy. Marketing is demand building: making the brand a candidate for people who aren’t ready to buy yet. Binet and Field’s analysis showed that a promotion creates a short spike that falls back to the old base, while a promotion combined with brand building settles at a higher base.
In practice, the 80% covers in-store visibility, sampling tied to purchase, and the salted caramel swap, and the 20% pushes the 3PM slump through social and other channels. His line was to harvest hard when you’re small, but never at the expense of long-term brand building, because otherwise there is no brand left to harvest from.
What do you say when your founder wants more TikToks?
Don’t cave completely, and don’t dismiss the idea either: stand your ground on the plan and offer an olive branch. In the simulation, the founder points out that Goliath’s gym video has 2 million views and that a friend’s personal trainer says everyone at his gym is mad for protein bars. The options were to say views don’t sell bars, to start daily gym TikToks, or to test a few alongside the 3PM plan. Chris admired the bravery of the first answer, said not to cave, and suggested the diplomatic offer to the founder.
For evidence, he cited a Kantar white paper which found that, out of every 10 highly engaging posts, 8 did not correlate to any sales improvement. Founders often prefer proof from their own business, so pull your own data. He also said social platforms will offer uplift studies, but they want you to buy more media, so treat the results with care.
He then pointed to Grace Kite’s paper Lots of Littles as a way to take on big brands that spend on national media: lots of small exposures through creator-led, influencer-led, and culture-led social, plus search and performance marketing. The caveat is a consistent thread, because activations that look and sound unrelated won’t add up. In the simulation that thread is one idea, the 3PM slump, delivered by creators based in Manchester and Leeds.
How do you plan with a sales team that wants your brand budget for promotions?
Write a joint plan with them that covers both demand building and demand harvesting. In the final decision, sales asks for more promotion money and the only source is the brand budget. The options were to hand it over, to give sales £10,000 and keep the rest, or to sit down and write a plan together. Chris said the third is one of the most important things you can do.
A joint plan should be rooted in the reality of their retailers and real consumers buying real product, not what you hope advertising is doing. It shows how their activity on distribution, visibility, promotion, and pricing is supported and accelerated by yours, so they can see the longer-term benefit of marketing spend.
What would Chris do with the £100,000?
In his small budget marketing plan, he would put money behind sales support, creators, and a little research, and leave a rebrand and a new website alone. In the opening poll the audience put most of the budget into research first and creator content second. Chris said research is useful but he wouldn’t spend that much, because a small brand’s money has to work hard. His list was in-store visibility and a product-in-hand sampling campaign, creators and social in confined channels, timeframes, and opportunities, and a swap of tropical for salted caramel instead of two new flavours.
His three takeaways were to fix the foundations first, by getting the proposition right, doing the research if you need it, and getting it signed off. Then pick a fight you can win, measure it so you can prove it and roll it out, and find your lots of littles. Last, bring the business with you, because a plan gets unpicked within minutes without it.
Frequently asked questions
How do you hold your nerve when a founder starts to doubt the plan?
Chris said to start with empathy and listening, because the project matters enormously to the founder and small things get amplified. Find out what they are worried about, then go back through what you’ve done together and check it still holds. You can adjust the end of the plan to address their concerns. Ignoring the worry lets it chip away at their confidence in you.
How do you make the case for a marketing budget when you don’t have one?
Chris said you need some money to get product reputation beyond your own network, and the best route is a test that shows it working. Start further back with published evidence, such as Byron Sharp’s How Brands Grow, to build the business case. Then ask what the business loses by spending nothing and limiting its own awareness.
How much should a B2B brand with a long sales cycle spend on brand building?
Chris said there is no hard and fast rule. It depends on your profit and loss, what it costs to find and convert a lead, and what competitors are doing. With a five to ten year cycle you need conversions in between to stay in business, so he’d expect a heavier weighting towards sales, perhaps 60% sales and 40% brand. Every business still needs brand building.
How do you get senior colleagues to change what they spend money on?
Chris said to start from what isn’t working. In his example, flat sales and weak repeat buying showed the current activity wasn’t solving the problem, so repeating it wouldn’t either. Find the cause, then fund activity aimed at it. Keep checking whether each activity works, as revenue growth teams do with promotions, and ask why you’re still doing it if it doesn’t.
How do you compete with a competitor that has far more money?
Chris said to pick a fight on ground a big brand avoids. In his example that was sampling and creator-led local social, focused on one occasion, two cities, and a few store types, with the results measured. Small activations only add up if they share one consistent idea, so keep the same story across all of them.
How should a small business split its marketing budget between sales and brand?
Chris said it depends on stage, budget, and competitors. His Oatsider example put 80% into sales and 20% into brand, because cash flow and a retailer listing were at risk. He pointed to Binet and Field’s 60% brand, 40% sales as the general principle, and said to harvest hard when you’re small without starving the brand.
Closing thoughts
Chris ran this as a simulation, with the audience voting on every decision and the chat full of answers to his question about what your boss is asking you for right now. The answers included more for less, and proper leads rather than marketing-qualified leads.
If you’re a team of one or two, with a founder who has strong opinions and a competitor with deeper pockets, the Oatsider plan comes down to a few small choices: one audience, one occasion, one idea, repeated wherever you can reach them. Chris said every principle in the session applies whatever sector you work in, B2B included.
Thank you to Chris for taking on a topic that case studies tend to skip.
Supported by Planable, who are offering 20% off six months of Planable with the code TMM20.